PDF Version

Asian Americans Advancing Justice Files Brief In Support of Race-Conscious Admissions at Harvard

Asian Americans Refuse to be a Wedge in Affirmative Action Debate


Norcross, Georgia, July 30, 2018 — Today, Asian Americans Advancing Justice (Advancing Justice) alongside the National Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law, the Boston-based Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights and Economic Justice, and pro bono counsel, Arnold & Porter, filed an amicus curiae, “friend of the court,” brief on behalf of a diverse group of students, including Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders, who support Harvard’s race-conscious holistic admissions policy.

The court granted this group of students special privileges, including the right to submit evidence and participate in oral arguments, so that the student voice can be heard in the lawsuit challenging Harvard’s race-conscious admissions policy.

Harvard’s race-conscious holistic admissions policy first came under public scrutiny in 2014 when Students for Fair Admission (SFFA) filed a lawsuit claiming that the university’s race-conscious holistic review policy discriminates against Asian Americans. Orchestrated by Edward Blum, after a failed attempt to dismantle affirmative action at the Supreme Court (Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin), SFFA has actively recruited Asian Americans to be plaintiffs for their campaign. As a result, Asian Americans have been at the crosshairs of conversations about affirmative action.

"This lawsuit is not about Asian Americans,” said Nicole Ochi, supervising attorney at Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Los Angeles. “It is about using Asian Americans as a cover for Edward Blum’s crusade to force every institution of higher education to ignore the reality of systemic racism and segregation that infects every aspect of our lives. Holistic race-conscious admissions is necessary to address that reality and ensure meaningful access and opportunity for all communities, including Asian Americans. Eliminating such programs will do nothing to remedy any intentional or implicit bias against Asian American applicants. That’s not what this suit is really about.”

Asian American Student amici affirm that they have benefited directly from Harvard’s race-conscious admissions process as applicants and as current students at Harvard.

“I was told that my scores were low for an Ivy League school,” said Sally Chen, a Chinese American rising senior at Harvard who is one of the Student amici. “But against that advice, I applied to Harvard and ultimately chose to write about growing up in a working class Chinese American family, because it allowed me to present myself as a whole person. When I reviewed my application, I saw that discussing my race ultimately benefited me in the admissions process because it allowed the reviewers to recognize that I had the potential to make a ‘contribution to college life’ that would be ‘truly unusual.’”

For Chen, being Chinese is an inseparable part of who she is and what shaped her life experience. Race-conscious admissions recognizes that and understands that bald numerical indicators like a test score or GPA are not the sum total of who we are or what we have to offer.

Student amici also attest that the racial diversity at Harvard has allowed them to bridge racial divides and engage in cross-cultural understanding in ways that would have been impossible in their segregated high schools.

“Coming from a predominantly white, upper-middle class Long Island high school, Harvard seemed incredibly diverse to me,” said Caroline Zheng, a Chinese American rising senior at Harvard and one of the Student amici. “I made many African American friends during my first year who provided me with perspectives that I previously lacked, which forced me to confront my own prejudices and privilege. ”

At the same time, Student amici contend that Harvard has yet to reach the level of diversity necessary to fully realize its benefits and that any supposedly race-neutral alternative that decreases racial diversity would be devastating to the educational environment and racial climate at Harvard.

"I support Harvard’s race-conscious admissions program and I do not think that Harvard discriminates against Asian Americans, but that does not mean that Harvard has done enough,” said Thang Diep, a Vietnamese-American rising senior at Harvard and one of the Student amici. “Asian Americans are the second largest group [at Harvard], but there is still a troubling lack of ethnic diversity within that huge label. The presence of Southeast Asian students, for example, is extremely low.”

The heart of this lawsuit is whether Harvard can continue to value racial diversity in ways in which our country has consistently fallen short: acknowledging the entrenched racism that still pervades every aspect of life, bridging racial divides, and developing racially diverse leaders in every sector. This lawsuit has nothing to do with discrimination against Asian Americans.

Asian Americans Advancing Justice fights every day across the country to end racism against Asian Americans and all people of color, and we recognize Ed Blum’s strategy for what it is: a thinly veiled attempt to use Asian Americans to destroy racial diversity on every campus across the country. We, and the student amici that we present, refuse to be used as a wedge. We stand together with students of all races to ask for more diversity on college campuses, not less.

Advancing Justice Contacts:
James Woo, (404) 585-8446, jwoo@advancingjustice-atlanta.org
Jessica Jinn, (213) 241-8817, jjinn@advancingjustice-la.org
Michelle Boykins, (202) 296-2300 x0144, mboykins@advancingjustice-aajc.org
Christina So, (415) 848-7728, christinaso@advancingjustice-alc.org
Brandon Lee, (773) 271-0899 x200, blee@advancingjustice-chicago.org

December 21, 2017: Asian Americans Advancing Justice Outraged at Delays on Dream Act, Calls for Resolution in January

December 12, 2017: Asian Americans Advancing Justice Condemns Statements By the White House and Attorney General Scapegoating Immigrants

December 8, 2017: Asian Americans Advancing Justice Rejects White Supremacist Immigration Agenda

December 4, 2017: Asian Americans Advancing Justice Condemns Supreme Court Decision Allowing Full Enforcement of Muslim Ban Pending Appeal Process

December 4, 2017: CIVIL RIGHTS GROUPS DISAPPOINTED IN SUPREME COURT DECISION ON MUSLIM BAN, VOW TO CONTINUE ADVOCACY

November 22, 2017: Advancing Justice Condemns Termination of TPS for Haiti, Calls on Congress to Provide a Solution

November 20, 2017: Asian Americans Advancing Justice Hold Press Briefing To Announce In-Language Hate Crime Hotline and Website Reporting

November 7, 2017: Advancing Justice-Atlanta, Catholic Charities and the New Americans Campaign to host a free citizenship workshop near Northlake Mall

November 6, 2017: Congresswoman Pramila Jayapal and other VIPs joining the Seventh Annual Community Champions Gala

November 3, 2017: Nationwide Participatory Art Project Uplifting Dreamers Comes to Atlanta to Underscore Urgency of Passing the Dream Act

October 30, 2017: Asian American Civil Rights Groups Condemn Racist Behavior During World Series and Welcome Punishment for Anti-Asian Gesture and Slur

October 26, 2017: Advancing Justice – Atlanta Disappointed with Georgia’s Court of Appeals Decision to Reverse In-State Tuition for DACA Students

October 16, 2017: Local Groups to Organize Clarkston Candidate Forum

October 11, 2017: Asian Americans Advancing Justice-Atlanta to host Duluth Candidate Forum

October 9, 2017: Administration Uses Immigrant Youth As Bargaining Chip

September 19, 2017: ACLU of GA and Advancing Justice-Atlanta demanding changes from Ga. Secretary of State's office

September 19, 2017: Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Atlanta to hold a free DACA renewal clinic

September 18, 2017: Advancing Justice – Atlanta to host Press Conference introducing expanded legal department

September 7, 2017: Congress Has 90 Days to Get DREAM Act Done

September 5, 2017: Asian Americans Advancing Justice Condemns the Administration's Termination of DACA

September 1, 2017: Asian Americans Advancing Justice, the Council on American-Islamic Relations, and NIAC Action Condemn the Government's Attempt to Make the "Backdoor Muslim Ban" Permanent

August 31, 2017: Congressman Hank Johnson, State Representative Pedro Marin joins Dreamers to Confront Urgent Threat to DACA Program

August 31, 2017: Advancing Justice Applauds Injunction Against Texas Anti-Immigrant Bill, Focuses on Leading the Charge to Protect Immigrants In Other States

August 14, 2017: Advancing Justice Condemns the Acts of Terror and Hate Displayed By White Supremacists

August 3, 2017: Advancing Justice Condemns Administration’s Use of DOJ’s Civil Rights Division to Further Its Anti-Civil Rights Goals

August 2, 2017: Asian Americans Advancing Justice Strongly Opposes Anti-Immigrant Bill to Slash Greencards and End Family Immigration

July 28, 2017: Advancing Justice Applauds the Protection of Health Care For Millions of Americans

July 27, 2017: Advancing Justice Calls Latest Trump Move Targeted Discrimination

July 21, 2017: Keeping Hope Alive for DACA

July 18, 2017: Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Atlanta outraged by blatant racism and hate message

July 17, 2017: Advancing Justice-Atlanta welcomes federal blocking of noncitizen registry

July 12, 2017: Voting Rights Advocates demands explanation for improper voter “purge notices”

June 28, 2017: Five Civil Rights Organizations Oppose Latest Immigration Actions in the House

June 26, 2017: Asian Americans Advancing Justice Disappointed in Supreme Court Decision to Reinstate Portions of Muslim Ban

June 19, 2017: Asian Americans Advancing Justice Strengthens Hate Tracking Initiative on 35th Anniversary of Vincent Chin Attack

June 16, 2017: Asian Americans Advancing Justice outraged at Verdict in Philando Castile Wrongful shooting

June 12, 2017: BLOCK ON MUSLIM BAN STANDS

May 27, 2017: ADVANCING JUSTICE CONDEMNS ANTI-MUSLIM ATTACK AND FATAL STABBING IN PORTLAND, OREGON BY A WHITE SUPREMACIST

May 25, 2017: A Civil and Human Rights Win – Block on Muslim Ban Stands

May 23, 2017: Asian Americans Advancing Justice Denounces the White House Budget

May 19, 2017: ASIAN AMERICANS ADVANCING JUSTICE JOINS OVER 30 CIVIL RIGHTS GROUPS IN CONDEMNING PROPOSED “BACKDOOR MUSLIM BAN”

May 10, 2017: Asian Americans Advancing Justice Condemns Passage of Texas Anti-Immigrant Senate Bill 4

May 4, 2017: ASIAN AMERICANS ADVANCING JUSTICE - ATLANTA PRESENTS SOUTHEATS 2017 | Asian Food Festival

May 4, 2017: Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law Secures Victory Extending Voter Registration Deadline for Georgia Runoff Election

April 26, 2017: Asking Governor Nathan Deal To Veto Anti-Immigrant Legislation

April 26, 2017: Asian Americans Advancing Justice Applauds Federal Court Decision Blocking Trump’s Anti-Sanctuary Orders

April 20, 2017: Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law Files Lawsuit Challenging Georgia’s Voter Registration Scheme

April 13, 2017: Asian Americans Advancing Justice Condemns AG Sessions’ Plans to Prosecute Undocumented Immigrants and Target Humanitarian Workers

April 4, 2017: Asian Americans Advancing Justice Mourns The Passing Of Trinh Huynh

March 17, 2017: Asian Americans Advancing Justice Condemns Increased Funding for Immigration Enforcement As Inhumane and Unnecessary Drain on Taxpayers

March 16, 2017: Asian Americans Advancing Justice Applauds Federal Court Order Blocking Revised Travel Ban

February 16, 2017: ASIAN AMERICANS ADVANCING JUSTICE OUTRAGED BY RECENT ICE RAIDS

February 8, 2017: The New Americans Campaign to promote U.S. Citizenship partners with Georgia Gwinnett College and Gwinnett County's Office of Community Outreach to host a Free Citizenship Workshop

February 1, 2017: Asian Americans Advancing Justice Strongly Opposes SCOTUS Nominee Neil Gorsuch

January 31, 2017: Asian Americans Advancing Justice Responds to White House Firing of Former Acting Attorney General Sally Yates

January 27, 2017: Asian Americans Advancing Justice Condemns Executive Orders Banning Immigrants and Refugees From Predominantly Muslim Countries

January 27, 2017: Could Voter Fraud Investigation Lay Groundwork for Trump Decimation of Voting Rights?

January 26, 2017: Georgia immigrant Leaders to Hold News Conference With Civil Rights and Refugee Groups In Response To Pres. Trump's Immigration Executive Orders

January 25, 2017: Asian Americans Advancing Justice Condemns Executive Orders on Immigration

January 24, 2017: Advancing Justice - Atlanta and Gwinnett Branch of NAACP Meets with Commissioner Tommy Hunter

January 17, 2017: Advancing Justice - Atlanta Condemns Gwinnett County Commissioner Tommy Hunter’s Comments and Calls on Him to Meet with Diverse Group of Community Leaders

January 3, 2017: Advancing Justice – Atlanta applauds Fulton County Judge’s Decision to Grant In-State Tuition for DACA Recipients